Most CEOs treat their Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) like the wedding planner of M&A deals—brought in at the last minute to make sure the press release looks pretty and the new logo doesn’t scare off customers.
That’s a mistake. A costly one.
If you’ve ever been through a merger or acquisition, you know the real work doesn’t start when the deal closes. It starts well before that. It starts when you’re still deciding whether this is a match made in business heaven or a forced marriage that’s going to cost you millions in couple’s therapy.
M&A is Like an Arranged Marriage—Without the Matchmaker
Picture this: You’ve decided to acquire another company. On paper, it looks perfect. Their revenue? Strong. Their customer base? Complementary. Their operations? Efficient. But just like a marriage, what’s on paper doesn’t always tell the full story.
What if their customers aren’t loyal to the brand but to a specific founder who’s about to take their payout and vanish? What if their sales team is running on personal relationships that won’t survive a rebrand? What if their market reputation isn’t as strong as their balance sheet suggests?
You don’t find these things out through financial due diligence alone. You find them out through market intelligence, brand audits, and cultural alignment studies—things your CMO is uniquely positioned to analyze. But only if they’re in the room before the deal gets signed.
Most Mergers Fail for the Same Three Reasons
M&A isn’t just about numbers—it’s about people. And people, unfortunately, don’t operate on spreadsheets.
Here’s why most deals unravel:
Customers don’t buy in. Merging two companies doesn’t mean merging two customer bases. If the brand story changes too fast—or worse, isn’t explained at all—customers will disappear before you even realize they’re unhappy.
Employees panic. The moment a merger is announced, employees start asking questions. If leadership doesn’t have clear, confident answers, top talent won’t stick around to see how things shake out.
The brand loses its identity. If a merger means rolling two logos into one without a clear strategy, you’re setting up a branding Frankenstein that confuses customers, erodes loyalty, and weakens market positioning.
CMOs see these risks coming before they explode—but only if they’re invited to the table early enough.
The Brand Question: Branded House or House of Brands?
One of the first fights in any merger is what to do with the brand. Do you fold the acquired company into your existing brand (Branded House)? Or do you let them stand on their own under your umbrella (House of Brands)?
Get it wrong, and you’ll confuse customers, alienate employees, and waste millions trying to undo a poor branding decision. Your CMO isn’t just a marketing person; they’re a brand and business strategist who understands how these decisions impact long-term value creation.
Think of it this way: If you’re acquiring a Michelin-star restaurant, do you rebrand it with your fast-food chain’s name? If you don’t understand the power of the brand you’re acquiring, you might as well be setting fire to your own investment.
The CMO as the Translator-in-Chief
Post-merger integration is where good deals go to die.
Employees are nervous. Customers are skeptical. Competitors are waiting to swoop in. Your CFO can’t solve that. Your legal team can’t either. Your CMO, however, can prevent an exodus before it starts.
They know that people don’t buy products—they buy trust. And if that trust is shaken, customers leave. Employees bolt. The “synergies” you were banking on? Gone.
Your CMO should be the one scripting the internal and external communication strategy before the deal even closes.
What do employees need to hear so they don’t jump ship?
What do customers need to know so they don’t switch to a competitor?
What’s the first milestone in the transition that proves this merger isn’t just an accounting trick but an actual step forward?
Why the First 100 Days Determine Everything
You don’t get a second chance at a first impression—especially in M&A.
The first 100 days after a deal closes set the tone for everything that follows. This is where competitors pounce, customers reconsider, and employees reevaluate their future.
A CMO ensures that the right narrative is established before confusion sets in. They craft a communication strategy that answers the essential questions:
What does this merger mean for employees and customers?
How does it make their lives better—not just different?
What’s staying the same, and what’s changing?
If you let uncertainty linger, you create a vacuum—and vacuums get filled with fear, rumors, and doubt.
Financial Models Don’t Predict Customer Behavior. CMOs Do.
Private equity firms and corporate development teams spend millions analyzing balance sheets, cost structures, and market share potential. But here’s the missing piece: data can’t predict emotion.
A financial model can tell you if an acquisition makes economic sense—but it won’t tell you if customers will actually embrace the change. CMOs understand sentiment, brand loyalty, and market perception. They can spot the warning signs that an acquisition looks great on paper but will fail in practice.
Waiting Until After the Deal? That’s Just Cleaning Up the Mess.
A CMO brought in post-merger is a janitor, not a strategist.
At that point, they’re tasked with damage control—rebuilding lost trust, calming frustrated employees, and trying to salvage customer relationships that have already soured.
But if they’re engaged from the start?
They identify risks before they become problems.
They ensure the brand story remains strong and compelling.
They guide messaging so employees and customers feel informed—not blindsided.
A last-minute marketing effort won’t fix a broken merger. But early involvement can prevent the break in the first place.
The Smartest M&A Play: Call Your CMO Before You Call Your Banker
If you’re serious about making an acquisition work, don’t treat your CMO as an afterthought. Treat them as the strategic asset they are.
Bring them into due diligence. They’ll uncover market risks that spreadsheets can’t.
Let them define the integration roadmap. A clear messaging strategy can be the difference between retention and churn.
Use their insights to strengthen the deal thesis. Understanding brand perception can validate—or derail—your assumptions before it’s too late.
The best investment you can make in an M&A deal isn’t another round of financial modeling. It’s a CMO who can make sure the deal doesn’t just close—but actually succeeds.
And if you don’t have that expertise in-house? Call me, Angelo Ponzi at Craft. We’re the advisor, a fractional CMO you need.
Before you sign the deal, sign up for the expertise that ensures it won’t flop.
Want to make sure your next M&A deal actually works? Let’s talk today.
Comments